← Back to the lecture: The Competitive Firm: How a Price-Taker Decides
Lecture 12 Recap
Why a small seller takes the market price, how it picks its output, when it shuts down or leaves, and how the firms' choices add up to market supply.
Class meeting 17 · October 22, 2026 · 10-minute review
A competitive firm is so small next to its market that it cannot change the price. It takes the market price as given and decides only how much to make. Where its marginal cost is rising, it makes each unit that adds more to revenue than to cost, so its rising marginal cost is its supply curve. Average cost answers a different question: whether to make anything at all today, and whether to stay in business when the lease or the equipment comes up for renewal. Add up what every firm makes at each price and you get the market supply curve.
How to use this page
This recap covers the October 22 class, the last lecture before Exam 2. Class covered the price-taking firm and marginal revenue, how many units the firm makes, when it shuts down or leaves, and how the firms add up to market supply. Three TopHat items ran. Read the four-step diagnostic first, then the lecture sections, then the checks. The separate Lecture 12 Transcript has the full explanation.
Use these steps whenever a question gives you a price-taking firm, its costs, and a market price.
What you should be able to do
Class started with Exam 2 announcements (see below). The lecture then took one firm through two prices, $25 and $8, and finished with three firms and the market.
A small seller takes the market price
Economists call a firm like this a competitive firm. The instructor does not love the name, since every firm that uses scarce resources faces competition, even a monopoly. What the name means is that the firm is a price-taker: its own output is too small to move the market price. Any firm can post any price it wants; the question is whether it sells anything. Publix could charge $100 for a gallon of milk, but people would buy their milk somewhere else. If Walmart in Boca sells more milk or less, the price of milk in Boca does not change. The opposite case, a price-maker or price-searcher (often called a monopoly), can move the price of what it sells. That comes after the exam.
Suppose the firm is one of hundreds selling the same product, and the market price is $25. The firm does not face the market’s downward-sloping demand curve. The demand curve it faces is a flat line at $25. If it asks $25.01, buyers go to a rival next door, just as no one buys gas at the station that charges more than the identical station beside it. It sells nothing. Would it ever charge less, say $24.50? No: it can sell all it wants at $25, so every sale at $24.50 throws away 50 cents.
Total revenue is price times quantity. Seven units at $25 bring in $175; eight bring in $200. Marginal revenue is the change in total revenue from one more unit: $200 − $175 = $25, the price. A price-taker can sell more without pushing the price down, and it cannot push the price up by holding output back. So for a price-taker, price and marginal revenue are the same thing, for the ninth unit, the tenth, and every unit after.
How many units at $25? · TopHat
The firm’s marginal costs for units 1 to 9 are $9, $8, $6, $5, $7, $13, $22, $30, and $40. The first unit brings in $25 and costs $9, so it adds $16. The second costs $8 and adds even more. Keep going unit by unit. The seventh costs $22, below $25, so it adds $3. The eighth costs $30: making it would leave the firm $5 worse off, and the ninth $15 worse off. So the firm stops at seven. The instructor put the rule as “marginal revenue equals marginal cost, if you can.” With whole units the two are rarely exactly equal, so in practice: where marginal cost is rising, make every unit that costs less than the price, and stop before the first one that costs more.
TopHat check. How many units should the firm make at $25? The answer is 7. “4, because the fourth unit costs the least” is wrong: the fifth, sixth, and seventh units also cost less than $25, so each adds to profit. “5, because costs start to rise after that” is wrong for the same reason: the sixth unit costs $13 and sells for $25, so it leaves the firm $12 better off. “8” is wrong because the eighth unit loses $5. (The first TopHat question, on the $25.01 price, was dropped.)
Given the price and the firm’s marginal costs, you can tell how much it makes. At $15 it makes 6 units (the seventh costs $22). At $25 it makes 7. At $35 it makes 8 (the ninth costs $40). As the price rises, the firm is willing to make more. Its rising marginal cost is its supply curve, and anything that moves the market price moves the amount the firm makes.
The price falls to $8 · TopHat
Suppose you open a restaurant in a leased building. You owe the lease even if you never sell a sandwich: that is a fixed cost. The workers and the bread, meat, and cheese go up with the number of sandwiches: those are variable costs. Average variable cost (AVC) is variable cost divided by output: the running cost per unit. Average total cost (ATC) is total cost, fixed plus variable, divided by output. ATC sits above AVC because it includes the fixed cost. In the slide’s firm, the equipment costs $10 a day and cannot be resold.
Both averages are U-shaped. At first, making more each day spreads the setup costs, so cost per unit falls. Economists call this economies of scale. Later, cost per unit rises. Marginal cost pulls the averages the way a newcomer changes the average height in a classroom: a shorter student pulls the average down, a taller one pulls it up. So marginal cost crosses AVC and ATC at their lowest points. In the slide’s firm, the lowest AVC is $7 and the lowest ATC is $9. AVC is $7 at both 4 and 5 units; ATC is lowest at 5.
Now the price falls to $8 and is expected to stay there. Marginal revenue is $8. The fifth unit costs $7 and the sixth $13, so the firm makes 5 units. The instructor’s trick question: the price line also meets marginal cost back at the first units, where marginal cost is still falling. That is not the answer. Look for the place where marginal cost rises through the price.
TopHat check. At $8, with the lowest AVC at $7, the lowest ATC at $9, and $10 a day of equipment that cannot be resold, what does the firm do? Most of the class got it right: it keeps producing today, but will not replace the equipment when it wears out.
| Item | Amount |
|---|---|
| Revenue (5 × $8) | $40 |
| Running cost (5 × $7 AVC) | $35 |
| Left over for the $10 equipment ((8 − 7) × 5) | $5 |
| Not recovered ((9 − 8) × 5) | $5 |
| If it runs: 40 − 35 − 10 | −$5 |
| If it shuts down: 0 − 10 | −$10 |
Running loses $5. Shutting down saves the $35 running cost but not the $10, which is already spent, so it loses $10. In the short run the equipment cost is a sunk cost, the idea from the start of the semester: it is owed either way, so it does not affect today’s choice. That is why a firm can sensibly run at a loss for a while. When the lease comes up for renewal or the machine wears out, the $10 becomes a choice again, and at $8 it does not pay.
Below $7 (the lowest AVC), the firm cannot cover even its running cost, so it shuts down at once. That is the shutdown price. Between $7 and $9, it runs what it has, but when the lease or the equipment is up for renewal, it does not renew: it leaves. At $9 or more (the lowest ATC, the break-even price), it covers all its costs and stays. In the long run every cost is a variable cost. Average cost does not tell the firm how much to make, but it tells it whether to be in the market at all.
A student asked a follow-up about the long run. The instructor’s answer: if you expect the $8 price and your costs to last for years, leave. You might first look for a cheaper lease; if rents fall, your fixed cost falls, the whole ATC curve shifts down, and you might stay. Losses are a signal from the market: the resources you use would be worth more somewhere else. Profits signal the opposite.
From one firm to market supply · TopHat
Market supply is built the same way as market demand: add up the individuals. The market supply of gas in Boca is the sum of what every gas station will sell at each price. A firm’s own supply curve is its marginal cost above its shutdown price: the lowest AVC in the short run, and the lowest ATC in the long run.
On the slide, three firms stand in for the many firms in a market. Their shutdown prices are $6 for A, $18 for B, and $28 for C. At a price of $20, A and B produce and C does not. The slide’s curves give A 18 units and B 12, so the market supplies 30. (In class, the instructor read rougher numbers off the chart; use the slide’s 18 and 12.)
TopHat check. At $20, how many units does the market supply? The answer is 30: 18 from A plus 12 from B. C makes nothing, because $20 is below its $28 shutdown price.
Below $6, nobody produces. From $6, firm A alone is the market. At $18, B joins, and market supply is A plus B. At $28, C joins. At $30, A makes 22, B 17, and C 5: 44 in all. The lowest-cost firm enters first; the highest-cost firm, C, needs a high price before it will produce. A student added that the more firms join, the flatter the market curve gets, and the instructor agreed.
This is short-run supply: the set of firms is fixed, and the question for each is whether to produce. In the long run, firms can leave, and new firms can enter. The instructor’s example: if two big AI companies were earning large profits, you would expect new rivals to enter. During COVID, many restaurants stopped selling for a while because the price did not cover their running cost, but they did not leave the market. They expected demand to return, and when it did, they reopened. Shutting down is a short-run choice; exiting is a long-run one.
Not covered in class. Class ended before the last part of the slides, on how profits turn into costs when rivals bid for whatever earns them (the machine example). That material is in the course post for this lecture, the first item in this module, under “Profits Turn Into Costs as Rivals Bid for Whatever Earns Them.”
Announcements (as given in class)
Exam 2 is Thursday, October 29, a week after this class. On Tuesday, October 27, the teaching assistant, Anna, runs an exam review, as she did before Exam 1. Her slides will go up on Canvas with the study guide. The practice exam goes up on Canvas on Friday, October 23: take it Friday or Saturday to see where you stand, then spend your study time on what is not clicking yet.
Bring a green Scantron and a pencil. Bringing a calculator is probably a good idea.
Do not memorize an example as a story. Use it to recover the economic principle.
| Example from class | Economic lesson |
|---|---|
| Publix and $100 milk; the dearer of two identical gas stations | A price-taker can post any price, but above the market price it sells nothing. |
| $175 for 7 units, $200 for 8 | For a price-taker, marginal revenue equals the price. |
| The bars at $25: unit 7 costs $22, unit 8 costs $30 | Where marginal cost rises, make every unit that costs less than the price; stop before the first that costs more. |
| 6 units at $15, 7 at $25, 8 at $35 | A price-taker’s rising marginal cost is its supply curve. |
| The restaurant’s lease; bread, meat, and cheese | Fixed costs do not change with output; variable costs do. |
| The average height in the classroom | Marginal cost pulls the average toward it, so it crosses AVC and ATC at their lowest points. |
| At $8: run and lose $5, or shut down and lose $10 | A sunk cost does not affect today’s choice; run if the price covers the lowest AVC. |
| $7 shutdown price, $9 break-even price | AVC decides whether to produce today; ATC decides whether to stay in the long run. |
| Firms A, B, and C at $20: 18 + 12 + 0 = 30 | Market supply is the sum of the firms’ quantities at each price. |
| COVID restaurants that closed and later reopened | Shutting down (short run) is not the same as exiting (long run). |
Answer before you open each one. Every question uses only material from class, with new numbers.
At $3.10 it sells nothing: buyers get the same eggs from other farms at $3. At $2.90 it would give up 10 cents on every dozen it could have sold at $3. Revenue is 40 × $3 = $120 and 41 × $3 = $123, so marginal revenue is $3, the price.
Make 6 units. The sixth costs $35, below $40; the seventh costs $45, above it. The six units add $9 + $16 + $21 + $19 + $13 + $5 = $83 (revenue $240 minus running cost $157). The friend is wrong: units 4, 5, and 6 cost more than unit 3, but each still costs less than $40, so each adds to profit.
At $32: 5 (the fifth costs $27, the sixth $35). At $50: 7 (the seventh costs $45, the eighth $56). As the price rises, the firm makes more: its rising marginal cost is its supply curve.
The shutdown price is the lowest AVC, $23.75, at 4 units. (The fourth unit costs $21, below the average, so it pulls the average down; the fifth costs $27, above it, so it pulls the average up.) At $26 the firm makes 4 units: the fourth costs $21 and the fifth $27. Do not stop at the first unit: look where marginal cost rises through the price. Revenue is 4 × $26 = $104 against running cost of $95, so it covers its running cost with $9 to spare.
Revenue is $2,200 and running cost $1,700, so $500 is left over toward the fixed cost of ($12 − $8.50) × 200 = $700. Running loses $200. Closing saves the $1,700 but not the $700 lease, so it loses $700. It should keep running for now, since the price covers its average variable cost.
$11: below the $12 shutdown price, so it shuts down now. $13: it covers its running cost, so it keeps baking today, but it is below the $15 break-even price, so it does not renew the lease and leaves. $16: it covers all its costs, so it renews and stays.
At $14: 40 + 25 = 65. Z makes nothing, because $14 is below its $16 shutdown price. At $18: 45 + 30 + 10 = 85. A higher price draws more from each firm and switches on the highest-cost firm.
Shut down, but do not exit. Below the lowest AVC, every rental loses money on running cost alone, so it stops renting for now. But the lease and the gear are already paid for, and the owner expects the price to recover, like the restaurants that closed during COVID and later reopened. If the owner expected the price to stay below the lowest average total cost for good, the shop would leave when its lease came up for renewal.
Variable cost at 10 units is $150. At 11 units: ($150 + $12) ÷ 11 = $14.73, lower, because the new unit costs less than the average. At 12 units: ($162 + $20) ÷ 12 = $15.17, higher, because the new unit costs more. The lowest AVC is near 11 units, where marginal cost moves from below the average to above it.
Bottom line
A price-taker cannot choose its price, only its output. Where its marginal cost is rising, it makes each unit that costs less than the price, so its rising marginal cost is its supply curve. It keeps running today if the price covers its lowest average variable cost, and it stays in the long run only if the price covers its lowest average total cost. Add up the firms at each price and you have the market supply curve.
← Back to the lecture: The Competitive Firm: How a Price-Taker Decides