← Back to the lecture: Marginal Analysis, Production, and Costs
Lecture 10 Recap
Where to put the next hour of a fixed resource, what a cost really is, why the marginal pulls the average, why marginal cost rises, and when a producer should stop.
Class meeting 15 · October 15, 2026 · 10-minute review · The last 31 minutes of class · Part 1; continues next class
The cost of making something is the best thing you give up to make it. Every resource has other uses: the flour in a cake could have made bread. Marginal cost is the extra cost of one more unit; total cost is the sum of the marginal costs, and average cost is total cost divided by the number of units. Marginal cost rises as you produce more, because you give up things you value more and because adding workers to a fixed kitchen adds less and less output. Every one of these decisions is made at the margin: put the next hour where it returns the most, and keep producing while the next unit is worth more than it costs.
How to use this page
This recap covers the last 31 minutes of the October 15 class. (The first 38 minutes finished Lecture 8’s slides; see the Lecture 9 Summary.) Class worked through four parts of the deck: the two-factory warm-up, Adam’s cost table, why marginal cost rises, and how many cakes Adam bakes. One TopHat item ran. Baker, Carter, and the gains from specialization come next class. Read the four-step diagnostic first, then the lecture sections, then the checks. The separate Lecture 10 Transcript has the full explanation.
Use these steps whenever a question asks what something costs, how to split a resource, or how much to produce.
What you should be able to do
This part of class started a new deck on production and cost. It covered the first four parts of the deck in order.
Warm-up: which factory gets the next hour?
A producer has ten machine-hours to split between factory A and factory B (the slide calls them lines). A’s hours return $20, $18, $16, $14, $12, and so on; B’s return $15, $14.50, $14, $13.50, $13. Each added hour returns less than the one before. Economists call this diminishing marginal productivity.
Splitting the hours five and five returns $150. Can the producer do better? The class went hour by hour, asking which factory the next hour should go to. A student caught a slip in the order, and the instructor corrected it: the first three hours go to A ($20, $18, $16); the fourth goes to B, because B’s first hour returns $15 and A’s fourth only $14; the next goes to B ($14.50); then A’s fourth hour and B’s third tie at $14, and so on. The best ten hours are four on A and six on B, for $150.50, 50 cents more than five and five. All ten on A return only $110, and all ten on B $127.50.
Even with two hours, the rule matters: one hour on each factory returns $20 + $15 = $35, but both on A return $20 + $18 = $38. The lesson: do not split evenly or pick the bigger factory. Give each hour to the use with the larger return for that hour.
What a cake costs Adam · TopHat
Adam lives alone and bakes cakes for himself. The flour, sugar, and eggs in a cake could make other things, such as bread. We count everything else he could make in dollars and call it Y. With no cakes, Adam makes $13.50 of other goods. One cake leaves $12.60, so the first cake costs him 0.90. With one cake, his total cost and average cost are also 0.90.
A second cake costs 1.00, so his total cost is 0.90 + 1.00 = 1.90 and his average cost is 1.90 ÷ 2 = 0.95. Total cost is always the sum of the marginal costs. Why does each cake cost more? The instructor’s explanation: each cake means one less loaf of bread. As Adam has less bread, each loaf is worth more to him, so the bread he gives up for the next cake is worth more.
The class worked out the fifth cake together. The first four cost 4.20 in all, and the fifth costs 1.30, so the total is 5.50 and the average is 5.50 ÷ 5 = 1.10. His other goods fall from 9.30 to 8.00. Every resource has other uses: an hour at one job is an hour not spent at another, or on the couch. A farmer who plants an acre of wheat cannot plant soybeans on it.
TopHat check. Adam’s average cost of four cakes is 1.05, and the fifth costs 1.30. What is his new average? Most of the class got the answer: 1.10. Add the fifth cake’s cost to the total of the first four, 4.20 + 1.30 = 5.50, then divide by five.
Add up the net worth of everyone in the classroom and divide by the number of people: that is the average. Now Elon Musk walks in. His net worth is far above the average, so the average jumps. Whenever the marginal is above the average, it pulls the average up; whenever it is below, it pulls the average down. Adam’s fifth cake costs 1.30, above his average of 1.05, so his average rises, but only to 1.10. The difference between marginal and average cost will matter again when the course reaches competitive firms.
Why marginal cost rises
The bread story is one reason. A second reason is diminishing marginal returns. With no cooks, a kitchen makes nothing. The first cook adds output; a second may add even more, because one can work the flat-top while the other works the grill. But keep adding cooks to the same kitchen and each one adds less, because each has less equipment to work with. The instructor saw the same thing as a bartender: pack more bartenders behind a bar with the same taps and ice wells, and they start running into one another.
Marginal product is the extra output from one more worker. On the slide, each worker costs 12 Y. The fifth worker adds 4 units, so each added unit costs 12 ÷ 4 = 3 Y. The sixth adds only 2, so each added unit costs 12 ÷ 2 = 6 Y. Across the six workers, the cost per added unit runs 2.00, 1.20, 1.50, 2.00, 3.00, 6.00: it falls while marginal product is still rising, then rises once marginal product falls.
A third reason: resources differ. A farmer who wants more wheat plants it first on the land best suited to wheat, which is poor for soybeans, so little is given up. Each further acre of wheat goes on land better suited to soybeans, so each extra bushel of wheat costs more soybeans. Rising marginal cost comes from both: resources that differ, and fixed inputs that get crowded.
How many cakes does Adam bake?
On the chart, bars show what each cake costs Adam to bake, and dots show what each cake is worth to him as the eater, the most Y he would give up for it. The first cake is worth 1.15 and costs 0.90, so he bakes it. The second is worth 1.05 and costs 1.00, so he bakes it too. The third costs 1.10 but is worth only 0.95, so he stops at two. The class worked this one aloud instead of as a TopHat poll.
The rule: keep doing something while its marginal benefit is greater than its marginal cost, and stop when it is not. The instructor called it “a very good rule for life.”
Not reached yet
Class stopped after Adam’s stopping rule. The rest of the deck comes next class: Baker, who is worse than Adam at making everything but gives up less for each early cake (comparative advantage); the third-cake trade that makes both men better off; and Carter, a cheaper newcomer, and what happens when the authorities block him. Two TopHat items remain. This recap covers only what class did.
Do not memorize an example as a story. Use it to recover the economic principle.
| Example from class | Economic lesson |
|---|---|
| Ten hours across factories A and B | Put each hour where its next return is highest. Four on A and six on B ($150.50) beats an even split ($150). |
| Two hours: $35 against $38 | A use can be worth skipping entirely if the other use returns more for every hour you have. |
| Adam’s cakes and bread | A cost is the value of what is given up. The ingredients in a cake could have made bread. |
| The fifth cake: 4.20 + 1.30 = 5.50 | Total cost is the sum of the marginal costs; the average is the total divided by the number of units. |
| Elon Musk walks into the classroom | A marginal above the average pulls the average up; a marginal below pulls it down. |
| Cooks in a kitchen; bartenders behind a bar | Add one input to fixed amounts of the others, and output eventually grows by less each time: diminishing marginal returns. |
| 12 Y a worker: 3 Y, then 6 Y per added unit | When marginal product falls, the cost of each added unit of output rises. |
| Wheat and soybeans on different land | Resources suited to different uses make each extra unit cost more of the other good. |
| Adam stops at two cakes | Keep going while the next unit is worth more than it costs; stop when it is not. |
Answer before you open each one. Every question uses only material from class, with new numbers.
Take the six largest returns, one hour at a time: $40 and $30 on bread, then $27, $25, $23, and $21 on pastries. So two hours on bread and four on pastries, for $166. Three and three returns $165; all six on pastries $132; all six on bread $111. Every hour used ($21 or more) returns more than every hour left over ($20 or less).
Total cost was 6 × $20 = $120; add $34 to get $154; divide by 7: $22. The seventh session costs more than the old average, so it pulls the average up, but only part of the way.
Total cost goes from $60 to $70, so the average falls to $70 ÷ 5 = $14. A marginal below the average pulls the average down.
Marginal cost: 1.50, 1.80, 2.10 (each drop in other goods). Total cost: 1.50, 3.30, 5.40 (the running sum). Average cost: 1.50, 1.65, 1.80 (total divided by jars).
Divide $60 by each marginal product: $6, $4, $5, $7.50, $12 per added car. It falls at the second worker because marginal product rises from 10 to 15 (two workers use the bays better). After that, marginal product falls, so each added car costs more: diminishing marginal returns.
Two. The first gains him 2.40 − 1.50 = 0.90 and the second 2.00 − 1.80 = 0.20. The third costs 2.10 but is worth only 1.70, a loss of 0.40, so he stops at two jars.
No. The friend compares the third jar’s worth with the average cost. The third jar costs its marginal cost, 2.10, which is more than its worth, 1.70. Making it would leave Omar 0.40 worse off.
He plants corn first on the fields best for corn and worst for cotton, so little cotton is given up. More corn has to go on fields better and better suited to cotton, so each extra bushel of corn gives up more cotton. Marginal cost rises because the resources differ.
Bottom line
A cost is what you give up. Build marginal cost from the change in what is given up; add the marginals for the total and divide for the average. A marginal above the average pulls it up. Marginal cost rises because each unit takes resources that are worth more elsewhere and because fixed inputs get crowded. Put each unit of a resource where its next return is highest, and produce while the next unit is worth more than it costs. Next class: why someone who is worse at making everything can still have something to sell.
← Back to the lecture: Marginal Analysis, Production, and Costs